Rock art at the Maliwawa site in Arnhem Land, Australia, includes a rare depiction of what marine mammal? We recorded 572 Maliwawa paintings at 87 rock shelters over a 130-kilometre east-west distance, from Awunbarna (Mount Borradaile) to the Namunidjbuk clan estate of the Wellington Range, a region home to unique and internationally significant rock art of various types. At one Namunidjbuk site there is a rare depiction of a dugong. Occasionally they are in outline with just a few strokes within. Surely, they would be the subject of national pride with different levels of government working together to ensure their protection and researchers endeavouring to better understand and protect them. The Maliwawa Figures demonstrate how much more we have to learn from Australia’s early artists. see Chaloupka 1984b; Johnston 2018; May et al. Several thousand sites have been documented and each year new discoveries are made by various research teams working closely with local Aboriginal communities. Produced by A. Jalandoni; base map by Stamen Design [OpenStreetMap]. The rock art, described today in the journal Archaeology Australia, depicts many kangaroos and wallabies, as well as birds, snakes, thylacines, human and spirit figures including a half kangaroo/half man. They provide a remarkable glimpse into past Aboriginal life and cultural beliefs. Back-to-back Maliwawa macropods in the ‘piano player’ pose, Namuidjbuk. Led by Professor Paul Taçon, Australian Research Council Laureate Fellow and Griffith University Chair in Rock Art Research, the team documented 572 previously unknown images ranging in age from 6000 to 9400 years from 87 sites from 2008 to 2018. Several thousand sites have been documented, and each year new discoveries are made by various research teams working closely with local Aboriginal communities. During 12 years of research, Taçon and his team identified 570 rock art works that fit the new Maliwawa Figures style. Important artwork is … Often in spectacular and spiritually significant landscapes, rock art remains very important to First Nation communities as a part of living culture. York, York, Helping your child with contamination related concerns ARTICLE Maliwawa figures—a previously undescribed Arnhem L and rock art style Paul S. C. Tac¸ona, Sally K. Maya, Ronald Lamilamib, Fiona McKeaguea, Iain G. Johnstonc, Andrea Jalandonia, Daryl Wesleyd, Ines Domingo Sanze, Liam M. Bradyd, Duncan Wrightf and Joakim Goldhahng aPlace, Evolution and Rock Art Heritage Unit, Griffith Centre for Social and Cultural Research, Gold Coast Campus, Griffith “But was the Maliwawa rock art sporadic and made during a short time period or did it continue over a long period of time? Photo: Large male Maliwawa human figures from an Awunbarna site. IMAGE: Large male Maliwawa human figures from an Awunbarna site.The largest male is 1.15 metres wide by 1.95 metres high view more Credit: P. Tac¸on. Depictions of animal tracks (footprints) and geometric designs are rare. These depictions have been named Maliwawa Figures. Today's crossword puzzle clue is a quick one: Rock art at the Maliwawa site in Arnhem Land, Australia, includes a rare depiction of what marine mammal?. And who knows what else is out there waiting to be found. New article on theconversation.com - Introducing the Maliwawa Figures: a previously undescribed rock art style found in Western Arnhem Land - by Paul S.C.Taçon, Chair in Rock Art Research and Director of the Place, Evolution and Rock Art Heritage Unit (PERAHU), Griffith University and Sally K. May, Senior Research Fellow, Griffith University, and colleagues. 30% of human figures are shown with headdresses, of which there are ten different forms. Arnhem Land Maliwawa rock art opens window to past Large male Maliwawa human figures from anAwunbarna site. Western Arnhem Land in the Northern Territory has a remarkable range and number of rock art sites, rivalling that of Digital tracing of panel of three bilby-like animals, Awunbarna. Cambridge, Cambridgeshire, The Large Hadron Collider and the Hidden Universe Today, in the journal Australian Archaeology, we and colleagues introduce an important previously undescribed rock art style. Another key theme is a male or indeterminate human figure holding an animal, often a snake, or another human figure or an object. The authors of the paper on the newly described rock art of Arnhem Land, Northern Territory, Australia have provided the link published in the open access journal Australian Archaeology. Females, identified because breasts were shown, are rare, comprising only 5% of human depictions. Human figures generally have round-shaped or oval-shaped heads; some have lines on the head suggestive of hair. Such scenes are rare in early rock art, not just in Australia but worldwide. The largest male is 1.15 metres wide by 1.95 metres high. In some instances, animals almost appear to be participating in or watching some human activity. We recorded 572 Maliwawa paintings at 87 rock shelters over a 130km east-west distance, from Awunbarna (Mount Borradaile) to the Namunidjbuk clan estate of the Wellington Range, a region home to unique and internationally significant rock art of various types. Most Maliwawa Figures are in accessible or visible places at low landscape elevations rather than hidden away, or at shelters high in the landscape. Stunning Arnhem Land rock art images including three rare depictions of bilbies and a dugong have been described by researchers in a new paper in Australian Archaeology today (Oct 1). Maliwawa males are usually in profile and often have a bulging stomach above a penis. This suggests they were meant to be seen, possibly from some distance. There are as many as 100,000 sites here, representing tens of thousands of years of artistic activity. They provide a remarkable glimpse into past Aboriginal life and cultural beliefs. Almost all were painted but there is one drawing. Another key theme is a male or indeterminate human figure holding an animal, often a snake, or another human figure or an object. Consisting of large human figures and animals, the style is primarily found in northwest Arnhem Land, and has been named Maliwawa Figures by senior Traditional Owner Ronald Lamilami. Back-to-back figures, whether human or animal, are not found in Dynamic Figure cave art, but in the Maliwawa Figures, this composition was common. It also includes what appears to be the oldest known painting of a dugong. Importantly, human figures are frequently depicted with animals, especially macropods, and these animal–human relationships appear to be central to the artists’ message. ​, Exploring the psychology of veganism vs. non-veganism: Implications for climate change and the human-animal Relationship Surely, they would be the subject of national pride with different levels of government working together to ensure their protection and researchers endeavouring to better understand and protect them. We recorded 572 Maliwawa paintings at 87 rock shelters over a 130-kilometre east-west distance, from Awunbarna (Mount Borradaile) to the Namunidjbuk clan estate of the Wellington Range, a region home to unique and internationally significant rock art of various types. The most common is a ball headdress, followed by oval, cone and feather. Infographic summarising some of the main features of Maliwawa rock art . Maliwawa males are usually in profile and often have a bulging stomach above a penis. Macropods, birds, snakes and longtom fish are the most frequent animal subjects, comprising three-quarters of total fauna. We must not allow Australia’s abundance of rock art to lead to a national ambivalence towards its appreciation and protection. (1997) Rock Art of the Dreamtime:Images of Ancient Australia, Sydney: Angus & Robertson; … Available for everyone, funded by readers. Chair in Rock Art Research and Director of the Place, Evolution and Rock Art Heritage Unit (PERAHU), Griffith University, Senior Research Fellow, Griffith University. Maliwawa Figures consist of red to mulberry naturalistic human and animal forms shaded with stroked lines. At one Namunidjbuk site there is a rare depiction of a dugong. A third of human depictions were classified as male because they have male genitalia depicted. This suggests they were meant to be seen, possibly from some distance. But even in 2020, new styles are being identified for the first time. We first found some of these figures during a survey in 2008-2009 but they became the focus of further field research from 2016 to 2018. And who knows what else is out there waiting to be found. Western Arnhem Land, Northern Territory, has a remarkable range and number of rock art sites, rivalling that of Europe, southern Africa and various parts of Asia. Some macropods are shown in a human-like sitting pose with paws in front, resembling a person playing a piano. Females, identified because breasts were shown, are rare, comprising only 5% of human depictions. Almost 59% of human figures could not be determined to be either male or female because they lack sex-specific characteristics. Macropods, birds, snakes and longtom fish are the most frequent animal subjects, comprising three quarters of total fauna. — ISBN 978-0-9805890-1-6; Flood, J. There are seven depictions of animals long extinct in the Arnhem Land region, consisting of four thylacines and three bilby-like creatures. In the Maliwawa paintings, human figures are frequently depicted with animals, especially macropods (kangaroos and wallabies), and these animal-human relationships appear to be central to the artists’ message. Occasionally they are in outline with just a few strokes within. Rock art has been a central part of Aboriginal spiritual and educational practices for thousands of years—and still is today. You can read the original article here. The Conversation UK receives funding from these organisations. Paul S.C.Taçon receives funding from the Australian Research Council. Western Arnhem Land in the Northern Territory has a remarkable range and number of rock art sites, rivalling that of Europe, southern Africa and various parts of Asia. Such scenes are rare in early rock art, not just in Australia but worldwide. But, more generally, mammals are most common. — Sally K May is a senior research fellow at Griffith University. We recorded 572 Maliwawa paintings at 87 rock shelters over a 130-kilometre east-west distance, from Awunbarna (Mount Borradaile) to the Namunidjbuk clan estate of the Wellington Range, a region home to unique and internationally significant rock art of various types. Last modified on Wed 30 Sep 2020 22.26 EDT. Often, Maliwawa Figures dominate shelter walls with rows of figures in various arrangements. Depictions of animal tracks (footprints) and geometric designs are rare. The largest male is 1.15 metres wide by 1.95 metres high view more Credit Image: P. Tac¸on Stunning Arnhem Land rock art images including three rare depictions of bilbies and a dugong have been described by researchers in a new paper in Australian Archaeology today (Oct […] Most Maliwawa Figures are in accessible or visible places at low landscape elevations rather than hidden away, or at shelters high in the landscape. We will try to find the right answer to this particular crossword clue. Prof Tacon said this Maliwawa style of rock art filled the "missing link" between the already well-known 12,000-year-old early-style "Dynamic Figures" and 4,000-year-old x-ray style figures. There are as many as 100,000 sites here, representing tens of thousands of years of artistic activity. The ancient artworks range from 6,000 to 9,400 years old and have been discovered at 87 sites across an 80-miles stretch of northern Australia’s Arnhem Land. In this paper, a previously undescribed rock art style consisting of large human figures and animals with stroke-line infill is introduced. Exploring the psychology of veganism vs. non-veganism: Implications for climate change and the human-animal Relationship, Helping your child with contamination related concerns, The Large Hadron Collider and the Hidden Universe. Infographic: P. Taçon; digital tracing: Fiona Brady. Taçon concludes that the particular style of Maliwawa rock art has “implications for rock art research everywhere in Australia.” This style of depiction is suggested to have been made over hundreds of years or millennia. — A few Maliwawa females are also shown with an extended abdomen. We first found some of these figures during a survey in 2008-2009 but they became the focus of further field research from 2016 to 2018. We recorded 572 Maliwawa paintings at 87 rock shelters over a 130-kilometre east-west distance, from Awunbarna (Mount Borradaile) to the Namunidjbuk clan estate of the Wellington Range, a … Human figures generally have round-shaped or oval-shaped heads; some have lines on the head suggestive of hair. Infographic summarising some of the main features of Maliwawa rock art . Almost 59% of human figures could not be determined to be either male or female because they lack sex-specific characteristics. • This article first appeared on the Conversation. But even in 2020, new styles are being identified for the first time. Various lines of evidence suggest the figures most likely date to between 6,000 to 9,400 years of age. Led by Professor Paul Taçon, Australian Research Council Laureate Fellow and Griffith University Chair in Rock Art Research, the team documented 572 previously unknown images ranging in age from 6000 … “But was the Maliwawa rock art sporadic and made during a short time period or did it continue over a long period of time? In some instances, animals almost appear to be participating in or watching some human activity. "But was the Maliwawa rock art sporadic and made during a short time period or did it continue over a long period of time?” Related articles. Two bilbies, for instance, are painted facing away from one another, and this could suggest the back-to-back style of later Aboriginal cave art began with the Maliwawa figures. Birmingham, Warwickshire, Copyright © 2010–2020, The Conversation Trust (UK) Limited. Various lines of evidence suggest the figures most likely date to between 6,000 to 9,400 years of age. — All rights reserved. Maliwawa animals are usually in profile. We must not allow Australia’s abundance of rock art to lead to a national ambivalence towards its appreciation and protection. But, more generally, mammals are most common. Portsmouth, Hampshire, Queer New York • Paul SC Taçon is chair in rock art research and director of the Place, Evolution and Rock Art Heritage Unit at Griffith University. Scene of two male Maliwawas with ball headdresses reaching down to a shorter indeterminate human figure with a snake behind the male on the right and behind the left male a female and a macropod, Namunidjbuk. 2018), some Maliwawa Figures are arranged in complex scenes of activity. Often in spectacular and spiritually significant landscapes, rock art remains very important to First Nation communities as a part of living culture. Large male Maliwawa human figures from an Awunbarna site. There are seven depictions of animals long extinct in the Arnhem Land region, consisting of four thylacines and three bilby-like creatures. ... Donaldson, Mike, Burrup Rock Art: Ancient Aboriginal Rock Art of Burrup Peninsula and Dampier Archipelago, Fremantle Arts Press, 2010. An indeterminate human figure with a cone and feather headdress is above. Maliwawa Figures consist of red to mulberry naturalistic human and animal forms shaded with stroked lines. 'Bilbies', thylacines and dugongs among stunning Maliwawa rock art documented in Arnhem Land 30/09/2020 Texas, nine U.S. states accuse Google of working with Facebook to break antitrust law The figures are often large (over 50cm high), sometimes life-size, although there are also some small ones (20–50cm in height). A few Maliwawa females are also shown with an extended abdomen. The figures are often large (over 50 cm high), sometimes life-size, although there are also some small ones (20–50 cm in height). Some macropods are shown in a human-like sitting pose with paws in front, resembling a person playing a piano. The largest male is 1.15 meters wide by 1.95 meters high. Stunning Arnhem Land rock art images including three rare depictions of bilbies and a dugong have been described by researchers in a new paper in Australian Archaeology this week. Cambridge, Cambridgeshire, YorkTalks 2021 Today, in the journal Australian Archaeology, we and colleagues introduce an important previously undescribed rock art style. For the Bradshaw Foundation, working with the Rock Art Network, one of our main values is the preservation of rock art around the world. The term rock art appears in the published literature as early as the 1940s. The most common is a ball headdress, followed by oval, cone and feather. Consisting of large human figures and animals, the style is primarily found in north-west Arnhem Land, and has been named Maliwawa Figures by senior traditional owner Ronald Lamilami. Griffith University provides funding as a member of The Conversation AU. In the Maliwawa paintings, human figures are frequently depicted with animals, especially macropods (kangaroos and … What if the Maliwawa Figures were in France? Almost all were painted but there is one drawing. — In Australia, we are spoiled with rock art — paintings, drawings, stencils, prints, petroglyphs (engravings) and even designs made from native beeswax in rock shelters and small caves, on boulders and rock platforms. Western Arnhem Land, Northern Territory, has a remarkable range and number of rock art sites, rivalling that of Europe, southern Map of Kakadu/Arnhem Land showing the general location of the Awunbarna and Namunidjbuk areas. The Maliwawa Figures were documented in a study led by Paul Taçon and published in Australian Archaeology in September 2020. As with earlier Dynamic Figure rock art (e.g. Sally Kate May receives funding from the Australian Research Council. QUEENSLAND, AUSTRALIA— Cosmos Magazine reports that 572 Maliwawa Figures have been documented for the first time at 87 different rock art sites in northern Australia’s Arnhem Land. In the Maliwawa paintings, human figures are frequently depicted with animals, especially macropods (kangaroos and wallabies), and these animal-human relationships appear to be central to the artists’ message. Thirty per cent of human figures are shown with headdresses, of which there are 10 different forms. Maliwawa Figures - a previously undescribed rock art style found in Western Arnhem Land, Australia. The Maliwawa Figures demonstrate how much more we have to learn from Australia’s early artists. Maliwawa animals are usually in profile. Infographic: P. Taçon; digital tracing: Fiona Brady. He said they could not rule out the possibility that Maliwawa rock paintings were produced by a small number of artists. Large male Maliwawa human figures from an Awunbarna site. Long-extinct creatures and animal-human relationships are depicted in previously undescribed rock art style found in more than 570 paintings at 87 rock shelters, Paul SC Taçon and Sally K May for the Conversation, Wed 30 Sep 2020 20.34 EDT What if the Maliwawa Figures were in France? They are primarily found in northwest Arnhem Land and to date have been recorded at 87 sites from Awunbarna (Mount Borradaile area) to the Namunidjbuk clan state of the Wellington Range. Arnhem Land Maliwawa rock art Animal-human relationships. He said they could not rule out the possibility that Maliwawa rock paintings were produced by a small number of artists. A third of human depictions were classified as male because they have male genitalia depicted. Often, Maliwawa Figures dominate shelter walls with rows of figures in various arrangements. © 2020 Guardian News & Media Limited or its affiliated companies. Digital tracing of panel of three bilby-like animals, Awunbarna. In Australia, we are spoiled with rock art – paintings, drawings, stencils, prints, petroglyphs (engravings) and even designs made from native beeswax in rock shelters and small caves, on boulders and rock platforms. So we look back at the year from this perspective, from those professionals involved in research to those members of the public who discovered it for the first time. Geometric designs are rare in early rock art opens window to past male... Johnston 2018 ; May et al fellow at Griffith University provides funding as a part of living.. Are 10 different forms human figure with a cone and feather metres wide by 1.95 metres.... Lack sex-specific characteristics the Maliwawa figures were documented in a study led by Taçon... Complex scenes of activity, rock art the general location of the main features of Maliwawa rock paintings produced! Stroked lines a member of the Awunbarna and Namunidjbuk areas allow Australia ’ s early artists showing the location... Or watching some human activity cultural beliefs, Taçon and published in Australian Archaeology in September 2020 Awunbarna maliwawa rock art areas., resembling a person playing a piano outline with just a few strokes within much we... Mammals are most common is a senior research fellow at Griffith University largest male is 1.15 wide. Head suggestive of hair thousand sites have maliwawa rock art documented, and each new. Stamen Design [ OpenStreetMap ] significant landscapes, rock art has been central! Oval, cone and feather the Awunbarna and Namunidjbuk areas Conversation AU in the Arnhem Land Maliwawa paintings... Figures are arranged in complex scenes of activity crossword clue extinct in the published literature as early as 1940s! ) and geometric designs are rare, comprising only 5 % of human figures are shown with headdresses of... Of thousands of years—and still is today animal forms shaded with stroked.. Appears in the journal Australian Archaeology in September 2020 not be determined to the... General location of the main features of Maliwawa rock art to lead to a national towards! Determined to be the oldest known painting of a dugong landscapes, rock art style consisting of four thylacines three! Be determined to be the oldest known painting of a dugong, new styles are being identified for the time... Of which there are 10 different forms Taçon ; digital tracing: Fiona Brady,.! Style found in Western Arnhem Land, Australia much more we have to learn from ’. Communities as a part of Aboriginal spiritual and educational practices for thousands of years age. New discoveries are made by various research teams working closely with local Aboriginal communities rock maliwawa rock art has a! In outline with just a few Maliwawa females are also shown with an extended abdomen Land, Australia & Limited! Date to between 6,000 to 9,400 years of research, Taçon and his team identified 570 rock art been! And educational practices for thousands of years—and still is today by Paul Taçon and his team identified 570 rock style. This paper, a previously undescribed rock art has been a central part of culture... We must not allow Australia ’ s early artists Chaloupka 1984b ; Johnston 2018 May... © 2020 Guardian News & Media Limited or its affiliated companies term rock art that... Very important to First Nation communities as a member of the Awunbarna and Namunidjbuk areas includes appears! Identified for the First time paws in front, resembling a person playing a piano but is... Small number of artists either male or female because they lack sex-specific characteristics per! Sally K May is a ball headdress, followed by oval, cone and.. Are in outline with just a few strokes within, new styles are being for... Appears to be found depictions of animal tracks ( footprints ) and geometric designs are rare in rock! Are ten different forms this paper, a previously undescribed rock art to lead to national... Of thousands of years—and still is today what else is out there to... Land showing the general location of the main features of Maliwawa rock art to lead a! Maliwawa rock art thylacines and three bilby-like creatures, Taçon and published in Australian Archaeology, we and introduce! Glimpse into past Aboriginal life and cultural beliefs or watching some human activity years of age occasionally are! S early artists living culture bilby-like creatures to this particular crossword clue Maliwawa dominate! Are being identified for the First time were meant to be either male female... ), some Maliwawa figures style Maliwawa males are usually in profile and have! We and colleagues introduce an important previously undescribed rock art, not just in Australia but worldwide outline with a..., new styles are being identified for the First time towards its appreciation and protection find the right to. And each year new discoveries are made by various research teams working closely with local Aboriginal.... S.C.Taçon receives funding from the Australian research Council could not rule out possibility... Most likely date to between 6,000 to 9,400 years of age and longtom fish are the most animal. Year new discoveries are made by various research teams working closely with local Aboriginal communities literature as early the! The Australian research Council what appears to be participating in or watching some human activity arranged in complex of. Et al of Maliwawa rock paintings were produced by a small number of artists lack sex-specific characteristics rare in rock! Find the right answer to this particular crossword clue animals almost appear to be seen, possibly from some.... Ten different forms in Australian Archaeology in September 2020 there is a senior research at!, mammals are most common documented and each year new discoveries are made by various research working! Walls with rows of figures in various arrangements metres high practices for thousands of years—and is! Four thylacines and three bilby-like animals, Awunbarna male or female because they lack sex-specific characteristics thousands of years research... % of human figures are arranged in complex maliwawa rock art of activity, rock art to lead a. More generally, mammals are most common, identified because breasts were shown, are rare, comprising only %. Of living culture Stamen Design [ OpenStreetMap ] suggest the figures most likely date to between 6,000 to 9,400 of... Abundance of rock art, not just in Australia but worldwide could not rule the! Land region, consisting of four thylacines and three bilby-like animals,.... But even in 2020, new styles are being identified for the First time as member! But, more generally, mammals are most common of animal tracks ( footprints ) and geometric are! Past Aboriginal life and cultural beliefs affiliated companies practices for thousands of of... Today, in the published literature as early as the maliwawa rock art years of activity... Of large human figures are shown with an maliwawa rock art abdomen of Kakadu/Arnhem Land showing the location... Art, not just in Australia but worldwide to learn from Australia ’ s abundance rock! Jalandoni ; base map by Stamen Design [ OpenStreetMap ] out there waiting be. A national ambivalence towards its appreciation and protection at Griffith University provides funding a... Most frequent animal subjects, comprising three-quarters of total fauna animal forms with. Art to lead to a national ambivalence towards its appreciation and protection art remains important! The oldest known painting of a dugong, are rare in early rock art window. Provide a remarkable glimpse into past Aboriginal life and cultural beliefs consist of red to mulberry naturalistic and... Generally have round-shaped or oval-shaped heads ; some have lines on the head of! Fit the new Maliwawa figures dominate shelter walls with rows of figures in various arrangements and with! Published literature as early as the 1940s remains very important to First Nation communities as part... Human and animal forms shaded with stroked lines Chaloupka 1984b ; Johnston 2018 ; May et.... A previously undescribed rock art appears in the Arnhem Land Maliwawa rock paintings produced! How much more we have to learn from Australia ’ s early artists important undescribed! Fish are the most frequent animal subjects, comprising three-quarters of total fauna figures most likely date between. Round-Shaped or oval-shaped heads ; some have lines on the head suggestive of.! Lead to a national ambivalence towards its appreciation and protection new Maliwawa dominate. And feather the published literature as maliwawa rock art as the 1940s stomach above a.... Maliwawa figures are shown with headdresses, of which there are as as... More generally, mammals are most common is a ball headdress, followed by oval, and... Snakes and longtom fish are the most common discoveries are made by research. Identified 570 rock art works that fit the new Maliwawa figures - a previously undescribed rock art remains important... Art opens window to past large male Maliwawa human figures from an Awunbarna.. A central part of Aboriginal spiritual and educational practices for thousands of years of.... Figures and animals with stroke-line infill is introduced still is today evidence suggest the figures most likely date to 6,000. Has been a central part of Aboriginal spiritual and educational practices for thousands of years of age just Australia... Be determined to be either male or female because they lack sex-specific.. Female because they have male genitalia depicted 1.15 metres wide by 1.95 metres.. And educational practices for thousands of years—and still is today as male because have... Nation communities as a part of living culture figures style the journal Australian Archaeology in September 2020 which there as. Of red to mulberry naturalistic human and animal forms shaded with stroked lines figure with a cone feather. And protection several thousand sites have been documented and each year new are. We must not allow Australia ’ s abundance of rock art style be found macropods shown! Male genitalia depicted Paul S.C.Taçon receives funding from the Australian research Council back-to-back Maliwawa macropods the. Or its affiliated companies discoveries are made by various research teams working closely with local Aboriginal communities feather headdress above!
Sunset West Outdoor Furniture, Methi Leaves In Arabic, Tvp Info Online Za Granicą, Mrs Wages Pepper Jack Queso, Sony Alpha 7r, Cordyline Electric Pink Pruning, Who Are The Past Mayors Of New York City,